Karanlık

How Noiseless Props Are Made For Movies And TV Shows | Movies Insider | Insider

Insider
Abone ol
görünümler 15 563 686
100% 393 000 0

Some objects, like paper bags, ice cubes, and pool balls, make an unexpected amount of noise. This can be a big problem on set, as any of these unwanted sounds can get in the way of dialogue. To ensure the sound team gets the best sound possible, the prop team will create silent versions of real products. Prop master Scott Reeder replaced loud pool balls with much quieter painted racquetballs for bar scenes in shows like "Friday Night Lights." Meanwhile, Tim Schultz of Prop TRX uses vinyl and fabric to make quieter versions of grocery bags, sandwich bags, and cellophane, as seen on "Entourage," "Mike & Molly," and "The Kominsky Method." Reeder and Schultz showed us how they found quiet alternatives to some of the loudest props out there.

Find more of Tim Schultz’s silent products here:
www.proptrx.com/silent-bags

And check out more of Scott Reeder’s prop work here:
trvid.com/show-UCTyv...
www.tiktok.com/@scottpropandr...
instagram.com/scottpropan...

MORE MOVIES INSIDER VIDEOS:
How Fake Crowds Are Made For Movies And TV | Movies Insider
www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqIaP...
How Hollywood Twins Scenes Have Evolved Over 100 Years | Movies Insider
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LEbHA...
How Fake Drugs Are Made For Movies | Movies Insider
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwMuC...

------------------------------------------------------



Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.

Subscribe to our channel and visit us at: www.insider.com
Insider on Facebook: facebook.com/insider/
Insider on Instagram: instagram.com/insider/
Insider on Twitter: twitter.com/thisisinsider
Insider on Snapchat: www.snapchat.com/discover/Ins...
Insider on Amazon Prime: www.amazon.com/v/thisisinsider
Insider on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@insider
Insider on Dailymotion: www.dailymotion.com/INSIDER

How Noiseless Props Are Made For Movies And TV Shows | Movies Insider | Insider

katma

 

21 Tem 2021

Paylaş:

Paylaş:

Herunterladen:

Yük bağlantısı.....

Ekle:

Çalma listem
Daha sonra izle
YORUMLAR 5 398
Ying Zhang
Ying Zhang Yıl önce
We need those quiet plastic chip bags in theatres NOW.
KingRichTv
KingRichTv 3 saatler önce
Noise
Woodsy the neck breaker
Woodsy the neck breaker 7 saatler önce
Crisp bags.
pineapple animates
That one guy would still find a way to make it loud
Nuggets World
Nuggets World Gün önce
100th reply :)
gabrielirlanda
gabrielirlanda 2 gün önce
Silent pop-corns.
naly202
naly202 9 aylar önce
The entire movie crew is phenomenal, yet only the actors take the credit
Dotnet
Dotnet 18 saatler önce
@naly202 "no need to jump like thar, dear" istg TRvid comments are something else🤣🤯
Ramiro Eloy
Ramiro Eloy 19 saatler önce
Actors don’t take the credit for effects and props tho so I don’t know what you mean
Galaxy Creations
Galaxy Creations Gün önce
no actor is taking the credit for folwy artist or writers 😑
father2
father2 2 gün önce
Thank the modern oscars for that
rubyy
rubyy 3 gün önce
@RGBLighting fr, idk what world she came out from
yungtown
yungtown 7 aylar önce
Love the problem solving. Major props to these guys. (No pun)
sad pee
sad pee 2 gün önce
@Darin Cates WOW ... you just replied to a youtube comment to demean them for posting a youtube comment.
Darin Cates
Darin Cates 2 gün önce
WOW ..... you just replied to a youtube video about wet paper bags.
Emerald
Emerald 3 gün önce
Guys we don't need to fight. We are causing a scene (no pun)
sad pee
sad pee 3 gün önce
@Arfan Eka Diandra yeah it was a very tumblr era meme. old like i said
Arfan Eka Diandra
Arfan Eka Diandra 3 gün önce
@sad pee your general vibe gives off "tumblr"
Dru Owen
Dru Owen 5 aylar önce
As a musician who records vocals and as an amateur sound engineer, this just hits so close to home. I remember being 13 and walking into record for my first time on a professional microphone, getting halfway through my first take and seeing the engineer smiling and laughing outside while talking to my brother. I thought I sounded terrible. He buzzed thru into the booth on my headphones and said “that was great man. Now this time, take the bag of nickels out of your pockets.” 😂 my keys and change could be heard on the playback. Thanks for unlocking a memory! Great video.
theflaminglitten 2019
@Darin Cates why did this make you so mad?
AB
AB Gün önce
@Darin Cates jesus christ man it's relevant to the video and an interesting anecdote. grow up
LIGHTNINGCHEGG
LIGHTNINGCHEGG 2 gün önce
@Darin Cates calm down
Darin Cates
Darin Cates 2 gün önce
WASNT ABOUT YOU ..... Stop making everything about YOU
Xavier
Xavier 2 gün önce
The fact that we never realized these details shows how good he's doing his job.
Heimiti Cuellar
Heimiti Cuellar 11 aylar önce
We need noiseless packaging for our secret midnight snacks 👀
Official Margot de pearla 🏝
Yes like omg pls
Josh A
Josh A Gün önce
YEAAAAA
[•_Akira_•]
[•_Akira_•] 2 gün önce
*hits the invest button*
kphoria
kphoria 2 gün önce
@michaela not everyone is your age lol
U R Phake And Gey
U R Phake And Gey 2 gün önce
I ain't paying extra for that tho.
None
None 10 aylar önce
The fact that we never realized these details shows how good he's doing his job.
Rickyticky Bobbywobbin
Rickyticky Bobbywobbin 10 aylar önce
I had always noticed the brown bags in shows that look really thick but never gave it much thought. Before watching this, I probably would’ve assumed it was for durability so the bags don’t fail during multiple takes
Rishi_Raj
Rishi_Raj 10 aylar önce
This makes sense when you realize just how sensitive the microphones are
HelloItsVG
HelloItsVG 10 aylar önce
Small details but soooo interesting
TONK
TONK 9 gün önce
Didn’t expect you to be here
this is an alt account 2
HEY HELLOITS VG OMG
liquidbraino
liquidbraino 5 aylar önce
@Daughter of the King Jesus was gay.
Daughter of the King
Daughter of the King 8 aylar önce
Jesus loves you
happygamingboy
happygamingboy 10 aylar önce
fax
Racquel Robinson
Racquel Robinson Yıl önce
I have NEVER thought about this in my life. Who knew a bag of potato chips needed a stunt double?
cathy sample
cathy sample 2 gün önce
@Anneke Kramer totally 😆
Anneke Kramer
Anneke Kramer 2 gün önce
I actually wondered why those bags of chips looked so fake, more I know: they are. Did you never notice that the bag is always perfectly cut open, does not have a seal and that never any ink is ripped off?
cathy sample
cathy sample 4 gün önce
next look at what actors carry. cups, boxes. lots of cups. the way coffee defies gravity when the actor forgets the cup is empty. otherwise, where's the flying mess? 😄
Anakin Skywalker
Anakin Skywalker 8 gün önce
@I will defeat every single Justin Y I will never forget that line.
peeta Malerk
peeta Malerk Aylar önce
@I will defeat every single Justin Y that’s what I thought too
Life is Weird
Life is Weird 3 aylar önce
Crazy, I always thought they could just isolate the specific sounds and mute some out. This seems like it’d be a lot of extra work, but ultimately better for the end product. Props to the people in the film industry for giving us the most pleasant viewing experience!!
RayoniXV
RayoniXV 2 gün önce
Extra work it sometimes better work. Especially when it comes to movies, using the phase "Just do it in post" can lead to what is now the norm for Hollywood.
Chase Him
Chase Him Aylar önce
My exact thoughts. They have the technology.
Angelina Albano
Angelina Albano 10 aylar önce
I never knew that this was a part of movie making. It's just neat to see the behind the scenes of every single thing/department that goes into making movies. I am definitely going to be paying attention for these props in everything I watch now.
FrickinFrick
FrickinFrick 10 aylar önce
I am so into these kinds of videos. This is an incredibly niche and high expertise job that nobody talks about, it’s so cool seeing how he solves sound problems
KentBenedict
KentBenedict 10 aylar önce
This and the destructible props are one of my favorite. They put so much effort in the shows and movies.
CrazyPangolinLady
CrazyPangolinLady 11 aylar önce
When you do something right, people won’t know you’ve done anything at all.
Alex Cisneros
Alex Cisneros 2 gün önce
Uncaught serial killers agree with you.
RR RR
RR RR 2 gün önce
every engineer ever
BlueCrown
BlueCrown 3 gün önce
What about surgeries?
XAVIERCUERVO
XAVIERCUERVO 4 gün önce
doesnt apply to love making
Not Jordan
Not Jordan 10 aylar önce
This is truly fascinating! I had no idea that such small and forgettable props can have so much work done to make sure that the noise isn't harsh on the ears! Very cool indeed.
thechannelitrollwith
thechannelitrollwith 2 aylar önce
I’ve actually always wondered how they did sound in some situations. I just assumed the audio would have to be dubbed in all cases but even if that was the case, I’m sure having noiseless props lends itself to concentration. Super cool stuff!
DailyFuse
DailyFuse 4 aylar önce
It’s so cool how much effort these guys go through just for the sound to be right. You would think the guys at the sound place would take care of that, but they implement it into props! They deserve more attention for how much detail and thought they put into the little things like this.
Klaus the German
Klaus the German 2 aylar önce
This was a really interesting angle I never thought about. In Germany the sound is usually thrown out completely. The artform is creating natural sounding environments with little means.
Dream Promkunya
Dream Promkunya 10 aylar önce
wow, never knew that they have to deal with this seemingly tiny but very important problem. So much work for something so normal looking. Kudos to everyone that takes part in making a film.
Lawrence Martin
Lawrence Martin 4 aylar önce
I Love this. I make props for use in theatre where mostly, sound is not such an issue. Nonetheless, the delightful skill and ingenuity of prop making to solve problems is key to my enjoyment. It also links interestingly to the 'fake' work carried out by 'boffins' and secret ops designers during WWII where specific dummy lookalike items had to be created for use by SOE and undercover personnel right under the noses of the enemy. Many of those clever souls were basically prop designers! I love this amazing work for film as shown here and the prop makers are 'unsung' (literally in this case!) heroes of the industry.
chef
chef 3 aylar önce
Wow never realized how innovative these prop guys are very impressed with the work put in.
𝕒𝕞𝕡𝕙𝕚𝕓𝕚𝕒𝕟 𝕒×𝕠𝕝𝕠𝕥𝕝
Wow, I never knew they used alternative things just to make it less noisy, I always thought they used effects or something to mute background noises. Has anyone else been that one person opening up a soda can, or chip bag and you get the loudest noise possible without trying?
Tasnim Tabassum
Tasnim Tabassum Yıl önce
So much more effort goes into movies and tv shows then we actually can even think about.
Ke A
Ke A 4 aylar önce
Ikr
Speeder84XL
Speeder84XL Yıl önce
Yeah! A lot of effort to actually make the sound WORSE (more unrealistic), than it would otherwise be...
Derek G
Derek G Yıl önce
​@DJ Kinney And of course, aspyish as you might find me to be, I realize that you might just be joking in good fun, but this being the internet, it's also quite possible that you were doing an ad hominem, that is, calling me an aspy as justification to hastily dismiss what I am saying as invalid. I was responding in case of that latter possibility.
Tasnim Tabassum
Tasnim Tabassum Yıl önce
@Derek G you sure have a way with your words. I'm impressed.
Derek G
Derek G Yıl önce
​@Tasnim Tabassum So I suppose I won the intellectual battle but lost the social one? :) Congrats to you I guess, but hey, if you want to know why I think what I think, well, as you can see, such information has been made available :) I'll change if you find holes in it, but I won't change to fit in with the group, that is something I won't do and refuse to do :)
Kodaav
Kodaav 8 aylar önce
Absolutely amazing, I realized some sounds in movies should be way more bothering than the are but didn't know the secret to it 😯
Victoria Adams (master_cheefn)
I remember noticing the brown "paper" bags at a young age and loved the VERY VERY subtle noises they'd give off and the texture they looked like lol it was satisfying idk how to explain
Ellie Cee
Ellie Cee 8 aylar önce
Shows how important set and backstage people are! Love learning about this!
Helga Geraldine
Helga Geraldine 10 aylar önce
I never knew they needed to make silent props for movies and TVs. I always thought they polish the sounds during post production. This is really cool. 👍
pingidjit
pingidjit Yıl önce
Okay that explains why movies and shows with smaller budgets sounded so different to me. Hearing heal clicks, scuffs, bags and all the other things that bigger budget productions can afford to silence. This makes so much more sense now. I was confused cuz you're filming with the same tools, why would it sound different. Now I know.
Aleks
Aleks Aylar önce
@Le-Johnny in real life your ears tunnel on the thing you want to hear as the world is 3d and your ears can kind of choose a direction, with high budget movies they simulate that very well for you so when dialogue is important, it's up front and clear, if sound effects are on focus you hear them loudly
Danijelovski Kanal
Danijelovski Kanal 3 aylar önce
@Le-Johnny Exactly,old Yugoslavian films were prominent for their shuffles,rustling,etc...it gave a lot more personality to the films...
Mika Hare
Mika Hare 4 aylar önce
@Marek Siciński most of the time you don’t even have access to proper on set mics. So yeah, it’s pretty bad. The audio sometimes is directly recorded by the camera. The camera ranging from everything between a Canon 300 to an iPhone 4 and everything around. The types of short films I’m talking about here are not near any big screen film. As I said the budget is usually nonexistent and the equipment is in the best of cases, borrowed from the local school/library/workshop. The people working on them go from qualified, to students to someone’s father or little sister.
Mika Hare
Mika Hare 4 aylar önce
If you have a small budget of let’s say 0€ without accounting for travel/food/equipment. You probably need to either redo the audio from scratch, or be very mindful in the preproduction of what you can record and how you are gonna do it. Usually limiting it is better if you don’t have anyone who can make a sound-script and edit it or knows folley/dubbing in case you actually included dialogue, you madlad! You need to pre plan production/recording and post production. Both are important. If the film is complex enough the number of scripts needed to keep everything on track will increase. Also, to the directors of said 0€ short films, be mindful of your staff. Like no one is getting paid, but you know, let them live and be at least comfortable. You are not the next Kubrick, and even if you are, 12+ hour recording days should be off limits. And yes, it will take longer than you think it will. Pre planning is important, for every aspect of a film. Narrative films are more design based than art, meaning planning, budgeting etc. And a lot of the time, seeing what equipment is available and figuring out how you are gonna fix the bad audio issue. Once I stop being scarred by the last of these projects, courtesy of said “future Kubrick” I will probably resume working as occasional script/general assistant for everything. But for now I’m making 10€ budget student art films with “experimental music” and relaxing a bit. Wait, why did I tell you all of this?
Le-Johnny
Le-Johnny 4 aylar önce
@Fugi-Diva 🕊😌 ok
goose
goose 4 aylar önce
Very interesting! It's surprising to see how many of the props found in movies/shows are noiseless.
Kelsey CoCa
Kelsey CoCa 10 aylar önce
I've never thought about that before, but I guess the beauty is the details that we don't notice bc someone did their job. also, would it be possible to use clear jello instead of silicone? I guess it wouldn't float
Creative Minds
Creative Minds 4 aylar önce
I’m sure post production audio engineers are thanking them a lot for this 😂. Honestly sometimes it’s just as easy to do ADR with some of those scenes, but actors are very expensive so the production company would rather save money on that.
julinaonYT
julinaonYT 10 aylar önce
As someone with sensory processing disorder i can really appreciate the quiet versions of these everyday things
raydunakin
raydunakin Yıl önce
This was really interesting. I'm familiar with a lot of ways props are used in movies but never knew about the need to make quiet versions of ordinary objects.
raydunakin
raydunakin 7 aylar önce
@Sofa Ⓥ LOL!
Sofa Ⓥ
Sofa Ⓥ 7 aylar önce
What an ordinary comment.
Manda Terry
Manda Terry 9 aylar önce
@iZetto o pm
shockofthenew
shockofthenew 10 aylar önce
@Mechanikal Bull speaking as an editor, the main reasons this is done are: 1. a take with a great performance being spoiled by prop noises overlapping the dialogue is incredibly frustrating and expensive. Background sound can be removed in post, but it's time-consuming and removing a lot of noise can degrade the quality of dialogue audio. 2. every shot in a movie is taken separately and edited together, so if the prop noise is 'baked in' to the take, and then you want to cut to a different take, but there's crinkly paper bag in the first one and not the second because the actor was holding it differently, that's going to be really hard to cover. When you take all that into account it actually is much easier to add background sounds in post!
bmxscape
bmxscape 10 aylar önce
@Katie Cottingham HAHAHAH you did not just compare dragging and dropping a mp3 file to "as much artistry as the most accomplished musician combined with the knowledge of the science of sound" man you are delusional
VeroRockGirl
VeroRockGirl 10 aylar önce
Having misophonia, I would love if we could just use those "props" as normal, honestly. I mean, we can recycle vinyl too, right?
Hailey DeBruin
Hailey DeBruin 9 aylar önce
We need more things for misophonic/neurodivergent people, and those with sensory issues in general
Arcade
Arcade 10 aylar önce
gggh i have it too this is why i have headphones/earbuds in like 80% of the time
JS Mariani
JS Mariani 10 aylar önce
As a fellow misophonian, I sympathize and empathize.
aueier
aueier 10 aylar önce
unfortunately, they’re way more expensive to make, time consuming, and hard to function for longer than a day. but your idea is great! maybe in the future somebody can come up w something like that
Artistic Anna
Artistic Anna 2 aylar önce
I love how genuinely happy Tom looks when he's doing the demonstrations
allotherlightsgoout
allotherlightsgoout 16 saatler önce
My friends make fun of me for sitting through all the credits at a movie theater, but these people really deserve to be recognized for their work!
Sir Crayons
Sir Crayons 3 aylar önce
I didnt even realize this would be an issue until now!! I just dont really notice the loudness of everyday things. Props (pun intended) to them for finding good ways to solve these!!
09mrbubbles
09mrbubbles 10 aylar önce
It's funny the amount of effort that goes into making these soundless props, considering the amount of, equally bizarre work that goes into adding the sound again later.
Carlos
Carlos Gün önce
It's so funny how actors have to go into dressing rooms to take off their clothes, just so the costume designer can put them in clothes again!
Fowey7
Fowey7 19 gün önce
I know that in movies usually most of the dialogue is recorded in a studio and it's not noticeable. like lord of the rings, most dialogue is from studio recordings after the actual filming and most people have no clue about that. but I guess in the end it's more about the budget and time available.
FH_Mio
FH_Mio Aylar önce
@Cadde I love that though! One of my fave childhood memories is laughing at Bud Spencer and Terence Hill and how unrealistically funny it sounded when they punched someone haha
FH_Mio
FH_Mio Aylar önce
Haha yeah it's like I heard the fat from milk gets removed and then added back in. I get it, it's always about having control over how much of what is present. Instinctively it sounds absurd, but it's what makes the end product perfect :)
Xenyon_pdmc
Xenyon_pdmc 3 aylar önce
@shadowXXe isnt the sound voiced over later?
WigglyJigglyTho
WigglyJigglyTho 10 aylar önce
Prop makers are super awesome and creative gah they deserve more credit
Octane Demon
Octane Demon 8 aylar önce
All those technologies are awesome But it would be interesting to make a movie with real props for more natural sounds
Tripp G
Tripp G 3 aylar önce
This is why I live movie making and movies!! It’s really an art form encompassing multiple disciplines.
Warm Snow
Warm Snow 4 aylar önce
I didn't know this this is insane 😂 amazing details and work I'm Really impressed
eSCAPE
eSCAPE 10 aylar önce
Oh man, I wonder how hard it must've been for the prop people to create an entire town to make less noise for the quiet place, lol
kiikii
kiikii 4 aylar önce
I never thought about how they manage these problems. Interesting video!
U R Phake And Gey
U R Phake And Gey 2 gün önce
I like practical fx like this (if it counts as that), especially now that movies feel more like a CG animation than a live action movie.
Claire Martin
Claire Martin 10 aylar önce
As someone with noise sensitivity due to sensory processing disorder I appreciate these.
The Struggling Guy
I always wondered how objects like paper bags didn't make noise in movies. This finally gave me the answer I was missing.
Alex Niedt
Alex Niedt Yıl önce
@q q q uack !! Sometimes, but this is typically a last resort, as it can be tough to get desirable results this way.
q q q uack !!
q q q uack !! Yıl önce
i always thought they silenced the video footage and made the actors do some voice overs to replace the dialogue for the scene lmao
Alex Niedt
Alex Niedt Yıl önce
@Ande Leon Dialogue tracks still go through some clean-up (often quite a lot), but then the foley team recreates sounds like fabrics, footsteps, car doors, etc. to place exactly when you're SUPPOSED to hear them. This way, there's full control over the sound mix and where the audio focal point is at all times.
TryinaD
TryinaD Yıl önce
@thelithiumcat sometimes yes, they do that. But that takes a lot of time and sounds very strange without the associated foley so these props look like they’re created to save time.
Ande Leon
Ande Leon Yıl önce
I actually thought they just eliminated the noise in post production. Turns out, it's fuckin magic
GREENWOLF 1337
GREENWOLF 1337 9 aylar önce
That's definitely impressive. Props to the props guy!
Hye Jin
Hye Jin 9 aylar önce
This is so fun to watch. I never knew its this complicated for the sound guy
KiosheKat
KiosheKat 3 aylar önce
this man is a genius. I wish my technical theater program had more prop focus classes.
leyuen
leyuen 23 gün önce
I never thought of that, I always just assumed that they somehow were ble to remove the sounds digitally or that they had some method of holding these items to not make as much noise or that they had good mic that filtered those noise.
Nyasha Warambwa
Nyasha Warambwa Yıl önce
Damn even the pool balls had stunt doubles
Vibez
Vibez Yıl önce
LMAO
ExpensiveMagic
ExpensiveMagic Yıl önce
stand-ins
mentally ill person with youtube
@Born of Pixels weeeeee
Born of Pixels
Born of Pixels Yıl önce
@Monke-MK5 thats... what stunt doubles are
Alessandro C. Drums
underrated
•Miss-Change-A-Lot•
Its amazing what a prop master can do.
Elizabeth M
Elizabeth M 2 gün önce
This was one of the most joyful videos I've seen in a while 😂 Seriously, so delightful. It's so cool!
Oliver Bush
Oliver Bush 10 aylar önce
I’ve worked in the prop department for many years and this isn’t as common as you think! You very occasionally need to make “soundless props” it’s often much more important to make “soft” versions of props and “breakaways” . still interesting however
Wild Cascadia Radio
Wild Cascadia Radio 9 aylar önce
Fantastic ♡ I really appreciate your work!
Nathan Kellogg
Nathan Kellogg Yıl önce
I somehow never even noticed that these scenes weren't using noisy material. Now I'm gonna watch a movie and notice how many props aren't making sound.
Mace
Mace 11 aylar önce
@Lily Delane Yup, it sure does.
Lily Delane
Lily Delane 11 aylar önce
@Mace my mom has worked in the film industry for 12ish years and I've done a few odd jobs on set and we have that same exact issue. Ours isn't with SFX, but just recognizing the same sets they always use when they shoot in Albuquerque, being like "it definitely was not snowing on this day" "this actor was a dick" "this actor wasnt even supposed to be here, she was CGI'd in" Definitely changes the way you consume media
Mace
Mace Yıl önce
@Maggie M Yup, it isn't impossible that I'll bump into some of yours along the way, with the invention of the Internet, the world really _is_ getting smaller, and everything can spread like a wildfire. And I'll agree, this conversation _does_ have that kind of "we're both stuck here waiting for the bus, we might as well kill the time together" feel to it.:-) I've worked on primarily Danish films, considering I'm Danish and all, but have made a few bits 'n bobs for productions in other countries as well, but I'd say that despite being half-way around the globe from you, I don't think we do things that much differently. Granted, the SFX niche in any country is inherently populated by crazy inventors, mad scientists, and people for whom it is just another day at the office when they order 2.000 rubber ducks, a drum of industrial-grade lube, 150 meters of rubber bands, and a spare set of machinegun barrels, so I'd say a conversation with an SFX dude from _anywhere_ would be just as interesting. And I'm also glad we had this conversation.:-)
Maggie M
Maggie M Yıl önce
@Mace @Mace Perhaps someday, you'll find some of my stories. :-P I love having conversations like this; it feels like we happened to meet on the street and just chat about our jobs. But if you worked on a Danish film, you're half a world away and that makes this conversation even more interesting. I'm very glad we could have it.
Mace
Mace Yıl önce
@Maggie M The movie was the Danish movie "Brødre" by Susanne Bier, subsequently, there was a US version made aptly titled "Brothers", I haven't seen the US version, but I found the scene from the remake here on TRvid, I recall the scene in the original version as shorter and bloodier without being downright gory, but the desperation, hopelessness, helplessness and eminent regret are convincingly portrayed by the respective actors in both versions. I don't know if the US version is worth watching in full, but if they did a decent job of this scene, I reckon they did a decent job on the rest as well. As for you writing, and the reasons for why you did so, I can only say good job! If writing was what made a tough situation easier to deal with, then obviously you did a good thing for yourself, and if you even on top of whatever happened, managed to piece together something that had _that_ effect on him, I can only agree wholeheartedly, that you _should_ publish. Who knows, maybe there's a screenwriter hidden inside of you.:-)
Lil' Debbie
Lil' Debbie 9 gün önce
I knew that they added sound effects in films for certain props but I didn't know they made silent props, thats crazy
Lucy Frenchfry
Lucy Frenchfry 10 aylar önce
Very interesting. I remember the first time I saw a Police light move from the roof to the hood after the car passed through a tunnel. I've been super attentive to details ever since!
J WW
J WW 10 aylar önce
Prop masters: making soundless props Foley artist: adding those sounds back
erravii
erravii 10 aylar önce
Making propless sounds
GeeklingNo1
GeeklingNo1 6 aylar önce
I just... I love cinematography so much. Like every single detail is thought of
Takoiami
Takoiami Yıl önce
The people of the quiet place universe: ILL TAKE YOUR ENTIRE STOCK
OfficiallyTrust Issues
@✝️Havi Lavi✝️ and if I spam in comments "God isn't real and here is a document of articles by multiple professionals with legit sources below them explaining why religion is stunting us and is a scam:"... how would you like to see that under every video you see?
OfficiallyTrust Issues
@Dog Dog I remember a channel with a song called dog dog. I believe that the name meant inferiority given the lyrics. Just saying. Anyways, i wonder how y'all would feel if i said "quit religion, here's an article on why religions are stunting our growth and why no god is real". Food for thought.
karan sharma
karan sharma 4 aylar önce
😎
Kim Wheeler
Kim Wheeler 11 aylar önce
@snakes As people have already noted above, mass production usually results in both reduced costs and increased availablity for everyone, so the product is more accessible. Often, products that are specifically helpful to disabled, chronically ill and neurodivergent people *need* to be used by others too for capitalism to deem them worthwhile to make. A good example is pre-chopped fruit and veg. This can be incredibly helpful for people with fine motor or fatigue issues, amongst other things (and there are other non-disability related needs and benefits for them too), but if no-one who didn't have those needs but just wanted to cook or eat a bit quicker bought them, they'd probably stop making them. Another example is wheelchair wheels Vs bicycle wheels - often very similar products, which should sell for similar prices, but because one is seen as a "specialised" product related to accessibility, the price is vastly inflated. Don't get me wrong, I get that things like schools banning sensory items because people who are using them just for fun are causing issues would be very frustrating and is something people should be mindful of. But the idea that mass interest increases cost and reduces availability is not usually correct.
MsJillVicious
MsJillVicious 3 aylar önce
This was weirdly pleasing. We need some variation of these things in real life.
mimet
mimet 9 aylar önce
Amazing, simply amazing. Some people are geniuses and so creative and we don't even notice...
Feimicha
Feimicha 7 gün önce
In the few times I was around musical theatre people, they used a lot of silent props because the sound crew would be furious hearing them
angelhbkghellen
angelhbkghellen 9 aylar önce
This kind of small details is why I’m in love with films
gil.gosseyn
gil.gosseyn 11 aylar önce
The irony is that the prop man takes the sound of objects out, while the Foley artist works to put it back in.
Tulin Firenze
Tulin Firenze 2 gün önce
Thought exactly the same thing.
Peter Pan
Peter Pan 24 gün önce
Once you notice Foley at work, you can't help but notice it for the rest of the movie. That and the jungle drums, or the occasional Wilhelm scream 🐊
ron d
ron d 7 aylar önce
or they simply dub the voices ... like they do for English movies in Germany and France (and the ol' spaghettie westerns with English dubbing).. all that time and effort spent on silencing background noise instantly worthless because the actual recorded speach isn't used :D
ÆRational
ÆRational 7 aylar önce
This way everything is on separate tracks and everything can be adjusted individually.
BetterLifeAhead
BetterLifeAhead 9 aylar önce
Shows how many vital jobs there are on film sets that aren't actors/directors. The people currently striking are the ones getting bad pay and insane hours to do all the little things that add up to a movie making money for the people at the top.
GrayWolf
GrayWolf 7 aylar önce
Would be cool to use some of this in real life
Jahmya
Jahmya 3 aylar önce
Bro ive always wondered how objects go silent in movies 😭 never knew it was a real thing
Legacy Ivy Terascale
Legacy Ivy Terascale 10 aylar önce
lot of times in movies ( most ) dialogues are too quiet, while action scenes and music are too loud you need a volume knob at your hand all the time
Kelli Suzuki
Kelli Suzuki 10 aylar önce
I only truly realized just how noisy all these everyday objects were when I tried to get ready for school while my college roommates were fast asleep... every open and close of any door/closet/drawer, every scooting of the chair or click of the keyboard, every turn of a doorknob and every creak of the bunk bed ladder, every rustle of clothing and bags...I could go on and on and on!
Marina Saburova
Marina Saburova 2 gün önce
Wow! Props to you for being so thoughtful when getting ready! Most people wouldn’t even care
TheHardys01
TheHardys01 4 gün önce
@Chase Him Chances are it's a lack of self awareness. Pity them.
Chase Him
Chase Him Aylar önce
Yes! My roommates dont understand. I think they're incompetent. Those are the noise that easily bother me.
Flower
Flower 9 aylar önce
@English Donut School HHAAHAH
English Donut School
English Donut School 10 aylar önce
Lol.. keep going i'm learning new words with you
Bolo the Titan
Bolo the Titan 9 aylar önce
God! They are so creative yet very technical. Genius! Edit: i always thought that they make the bag/plastic noises disappear during editing.
raycho
raycho 5 aylar önce
This is something I literally never would've thought about or known about, fascinating!!
Tobi Those Notes
Tobi Those Notes 9 aylar önce
I thought that those noises were usually removed in the ADR process. I read in a forum that ADR was used a lot on films, some even said that usually in the scenes the final audio was mostly recorded later. But watching this video seems like it's much preferable and common to capture and keep the real audio of the scene.
Paisleigh
Paisleigh 4 aylar önce
it probably a mix of both! having quieter props makes it easier for sound engineers and the foley people to go in and remove that small amount of noise rather than a large amount without messing up other audio recorded at the same time that they want to keep
Arcian
Arcian 4 aylar önce
Damn, never realized sound was this much of a problem on set. Makes perfect sense when you think about it, though.
Aisadal
Aisadal Yıl önce
Damn, never knew the props in movie were specifically made to be soundless!
tabundo001
tabundo001 Yıl önce
@Alex Niedt I'm aware 😁
Alex Niedt
Alex Niedt Yıl önce
@tabundo001 But in far higher quality, and then all those sounds can be carried over when dialogue is replaced for dub tracks for various regions internationally.
Aadil Hussain
Aadil Hussain Yıl önce
@James Watson Atheist Gamer Amber Heardn't
tabundo001
tabundo001 Yıl önce
What's funny is that after everything is recorded as silent as possible, then Foley artist recreate those sounds from scratch during post production 😂😂
Paskky
Paskky Yıl önce
@Victor Emisho Who cares m8
Dilip kumar Borkotoky
Dilip kumar Borkotoky 10 aylar önce
Never thought that I would see Eddie Van Halen doing silent movie props. Dude is literally multi talented
Leyla Karaaslan
Leyla Karaaslan 9 aylar önce
Without all the objects that sound different, video making is already a lot of work. I'm into a 3 year education for a few months now and it's a lot of work to make it catchy already, without all the silent items too. But I loooove making video's!
TheMindEclectic
TheMindEclectic 5 gün önce
I just wanna know what scenes would sound like with normal items cause they always feel abnormally quiet
Noah Triumph
Noah Triumph 9 aylar önce
I know this video is very informative and educates the audience but at the same time it's kills your excitement when watching your big screen or favourite series.
Alice Buckland
Alice Buckland Yıl önce
The trick here is that they don't want the props to mask the dialogue, so in post production those sounds are edited back in. The result is a good balance between "touch-sounds" and dialogue - you will still hear the intended sound of the props!
Anton Galazyuk
Anton Galazyuk 10 aylar önce
@Ascab I've played around with mics. If you set even a cheap one right they will hear a nose being scratched from 6 feet away. Best to remove as much as possible and mix it back in.
the CROKODIAL
the CROKODIAL 10 aylar önce
@Owi Owi wrong comment man
toasterbath
toasterbath 11 aylar önce
Yup!
Kayla Nicholson
Kayla Nicholson 11 aylar önce
Exactly! And I love watching Foley being made it’s so fun
Inas Bosch
Inas Bosch 11 aylar önce
@Le-Johnny Not sure if you got the gist of it
SYKA
SYKA 10 aylar önce
Props to these people for make the biggest difference for the movie production.
Smith Hoowe
Smith Hoowe 9 aylar önce
I wish EVERYTHING was sound proofed! Sometimes the world to too loud.
Basil Vino
Basil Vino 2 aylar önce
I’ve often commented/wondered about the HUGE disparity between our current level of video processing versus audio processing technology. We can clean, edit, composite, green-screen, mo-cap, we can insert elements with rotoscoping and virtual rotoscoping, we can remove people’s legs, swap heads, and do just about anything with video and make it believable. But we can’t clean up a phone call on the radio or make someone sound clear giving a speech outdoors. It’s insane.
zMatt05
zMatt05 10 aylar önce
god i want these in my daily life, it's such a more soothing sound
TheGuyWhoIsSitting
TheGuyWhoIsSitting 11 aylar önce
“Real cows don’t look like cows on film, so we paint horses to look like cows” “What do you do when you want to show horses on film?” “We usually glue some cats together”
Amry
Amry 2 gün önce
Giddy up, moo.
Samantha Kim Manoban
Samantha Kim Manoban 4 aylar önce
This is kinda dark if you think about it deeply😂
Spectre Stain
Spectre Stain 8 aylar önce
@Nico com c And what a funny joke it was, I could've never continued on with my life the same way if I hadn't seen this gem of a joke, my reality as a whole would've crumbled and shattered
Cherio체리
Cherio체리 8 aylar önce
LMAO help
bmxscape
bmxscape 9 aylar önce
@Abel Flores Mite you caught me, i havn't wasted 12,144 minutes of my life watching every episode of the Simpsons i have a life
yaseen bshina
yaseen bshina 4 gün önce
I thought sound engineers edited these noises out and amplified the dialogue. This is very creative
Stephanie Papaleo
Stephanie Papaleo 4 aylar önce
I love the sound of high heels clicking or men’s dress shoes clicking (I heard they use wood blocks to simulate the sound where there is none)
Belgand
Belgand 4 gün önce
I've often wondered why many prop bags of chips look so off. Overly smooth, the opening is too round, etc. They look a little too obviously like props. I always assumed it was just part of the process of making them as one-offs that weren't worn in enough or something but this makes far more sense.
tlahmed
tlahmed Gün önce
Yes! I know exactly what you’re talking about.
Triad3Force
Triad3Force 3 gün önce
Props, foley, makeup, lighting, etc. are all unsung heroes of the entertainment industry
Andrey Tskhay
Andrey Tskhay Yıl önce
let's just pay respect to the people that put their efforts to solve problems that a regular viewer would never think of.
Lee🦭
Lee🦭 Yıl önce
@mr. pink 1. That's not even pessimistic, what is pessimism to you? 2. pessimism isn't even bad, I mean you're either correct or pleasantly surprised
FOS
FOS Yıl önce
@mr. pink that's just the truth, it's taught in every field When you solved the problem, no one notice it, If the problem isn't solved, everyone would notice it I learn that before watching this video
Jamie
Jamie Yıl önce
@mr. pink How in the world is that negative thinking? It's just a fact. If the loud things made loud noises, people would notice. Lmao
mr. pink
mr. pink Yıl önce
@F.P how can you live with yourself why are you such a negative thinking pessimist
Leslie
Leslie 10 aylar önce
I never realized how unrealistic is was for things like paper bags to be so silent in films and tv.
egbertus
egbertus 10 aylar önce
I love they work so hard to remove sound just for the sounds to be put back in post production
Austin Hernandez
Austin Hernandez 4 aylar önce
I would like to see a movie without sound props. We hear these noises everyday but still manage to talk and communicate with others with no problems. I guess it's the acoustics, would sound different when recorded and in theaters.
Lu
Lu 25 gün önce
I always wondered why plastic bags sound so incredibly amazing and asmr-y in movies, and in real life they sound so horrible.
Hfar
Hfar Yıl önce
I remember a professor once told me "Background sound in a movie is like salt in a soup: you can always add it in later but you sure can't take it out if it's already mixed in."
mushy
mushy 4 aylar önce
@zycie_ "a comment about background sound" Shows your poor education. The comment is about his professor in college telling him b.s. about soup cans
zycie_
zycie_ 4 aylar önce
@mushy was it.. really necessary to comment about degrees on a video about background sound.. a comment about background sound?
AlanDunaway3000
AlanDunaway3000 5 aylar önce
In fact, you can. If you have a layer of background noise before the spoken line, you can pass a noise reduction filter like ReaFIR or RNNoise.
MissionControl
MissionControl 5 aylar önce
@mushy why can't people like you just let people be happy
Christo Gaydarov
Christo Gaydarov 3 aylar önce
As a sound engineer the silent props and the people who make them are a saving grace.
Sonraki
Biggest FOAM rc airplane Crashes!
12:49
CARNIVAL SCAM SCIENCE- and how to win
10:53
How Hard Candy Is Made | WIRED
13:22
görünümler 9 800 000
Testing Netflix's breakable movie props
13:25
I bought the THINNEST Tech in the world.
17:15
Biggest FOAM rc airplane Crashes!
12:49