Karanlık

Captured Soviet Female Soldiers - How Did the Germans Treat Them?

Mark Felton Productions
görünümler 3 693 991
96% 68 000 2 500

Thanks to Curiosity Stream for sponsoring today’s video. Go to curiositystream.thld.co/markf... and use code markfelton to save 25% off today, that’s only $14.99 a year.

Dr. Mark Felton is a well-known British historian, the author of 22 non-fiction books, including bestsellers 'Zero Night' and 'Castle of the Eagles', both currently being developed into movies in Hollywood. In addition to writing, Mark also appears regularly in television documentaries around the world, including on The History Channel, Netflix, National Geographic, Quest, American Heroes Channel and RMC Decouverte. His books have formed the background to several TV and radio documentaries. More information about Mark can be found at: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Fe...

Visit my audio book channel 'War Stories with Mark Felton': trvid.com/video/video-xszsAzbHcPE.html

Help support my channel:
www.paypal.me/markfeltonprodu...
www.patreon.com/markfeltonpro...

Disclaimer: All opinions and comments expressed in the 'Comments' section do not reflect the opinions of Mark Felton Productions. All opinions and comments should contribute to the dialogue. Mark Felton Productions does not condone written attacks, insults, racism, sexism, extremism, violence or otherwise questionable comments or material in the 'Comments' section, and reserves the right to delete any comment violating this rule or to block any poster from the channel.

Credit: US National Archives
Thumbnail coloration by Za Rodinu

katma

 

21 Eyl 2021

Paylaş:

Paylaş:

Herunterladen:

Yük bağlantısı.....

Ekle:

Çalma listem
Daha sonra izle
YORUMLAR 11 150
Robert De
Robert De 34 dakika önce
There only one thing worse than forcing women to enter combat, that is to shoot a woman who surrendered after being forced into combat.
Living on Park Avenue in Manhattan
It is widely known in Russia that Yuri Gagarin had never been in space. And not only in Russia. The American Association of Astronauts at first refused to register the flight of Yuri Gagarin - he was supposed to arrive and come out from the spacecraft. The Soviets claimed that he jumped with a parachute from spacecraft. There was no one single photo of the Earth taken from the spacecraft, neither a video. But there were videos of the dogs - sent to space before the supposed flight of Yuri Gagarin. During the very first interview with the journalists - Yuri Gagarine had to invent - since nobody had been in the space yet. - USA
Living on Park Avenue in Manhattan
Let me tell you something, with due respect, Dr. Felton - that you might didn't hear about. Do you know that Yuri Gagarine had never been in the space? The sputnik orbited the Earth without Yuri Gagarine - he was found standing on his parachute close to the sputnik after the sputnik landed. The reason was - that the exit door of the sputnik wasn't closing. Nikita Khrushchev ordered to send the sputnik without Yuri Gagarine since the Appollo had been scheduled to fly 1 month later. Nikita desperately wanted to prove the superiority of the communist system. Therefore, the first man in the space had to be a communist.
MrAkurvaeletbe
MrAkurvaeletbe Saatler önce
what do you mean by "illegal order" ? 7:10 how do you know they are doing it for fun? Why do you have to add your own assumptions into videos like this? And to be honest it looks like those prisoners are also smiling.
Living on Park Avenue in Manhattan
My father brought from Germany - as a souvenir - 2 enormous suitcases, filled with the German Encyclopedia in German. BUT. I have never seen such refined quality of the cover, the pictures inside. Each volume was a masterpiece.
morzh1978
morzh1978 7 saatler önce
The Soviets took their revenge in form of "Kill the German!" propaganda (entirely un-Communist in essence, BTW), as well as "preemptive measures". Practical implementation was dispersion of Volgan Germans community (after sending in spies to learn of these Soviet FolkDeutsche mindset) initially, and total expulsion of Germans / Germanized Baltic Prussians from Eastern Prussia. Also mortality rate of German POW's in SOviet camps could easily exess 70% (as these were often considered "inhuman public enemies, arch foes of our lifestyle and folk, both" rather than captured servicemen). It is amazing how swiftly Gitler's concept of "total war" backfired.
hughbo52
hughbo52 12 saatler önce
Only the best work from Mark.
MIG 17
MIG 17 12 saatler önce
I mean what did the Russians expect to happen when they threw their countries daughters into the meat grinder? That they were going to be given a pass on the brutalities of war? Very sad how many lives were ruined in the name of socialism and communism.
mbayoumi1
mbayoumi1 13 saatler önce
On the other hand, what british, russian, and american soliders did for women in germany?
skyway minicabs
skyway minicabs 14 saatler önce
To be executed "on principle" is something only the Germans could come out with
Alan Amiel
Alan Amiel 14 saatler önce
That these German atrocities were committed by the heer forever stains the reputation of Germany.
friendofcoal
friendofcoal 16 saatler önce
Right after the invasion of the ussr, it was reported that some captured female russian prisoners actually bit off the penis' of the german soldiers while they were being sexually assaulted after capture. This is why the Germans ordered the execution of female russian prisoners, with the hopes that soldiers wouldn't become casualties from the female russian prisoners.
Bluetop Guitar
Bluetop Guitar 18 saatler önce
Horrible nazi ideology. No wonder the russians treated them so horribly when they lost. Awful
the GLOSSA channel
the GLOSSA channel 19 saatler önce
Video starts at 1:11
ellery eggen
ellery eggen 20 saatler önce
I honestly did not believe anything could be more more horrific than other more well publicized atrocities. Never occured to me that women would have it worse than men. Please to remember, our neighbors, members of our communities and our coworkers are capable of this type of abhorrent behaviour. I'm glad I'm old.
The Shadow Man
The Shadow Man 20 saatler önce
And yet Germany now dares to lecture Russia on human rights. Utter hypocrisy
Jack
Jack 21 saatler önce
Women of Berlin - How did the Russians treat them
J. G.
J. G. 22 saatler önce
Although I don't agree with the propagated agenda of Both Germany and Russia, learning more about the roles these Russian Women played during WWII has caused me to have a greater respect and high regard for them.
scot niver
scot niver Gün önce
Flintin Wieber Rifle Broad.. I did not know about this. Thanks for the presentation and analysis. Now I am more informed.
Theodore Vegh
Theodore Vegh Gün önce
What percentage of the "Russian" Female Soldiers fighting on the front line against the European Race Men of Germany, Hungary and Italy were Jews? 100%? - TAV ❤ 🇺🇸 🌎 👍
Regina Billotti
Regina Billotti 7 saatler önce
@Theodore Vegh So you consider something "virtually incomprehensible," and therefore you are going to ignore all historical records that don't conform to your imagination. Got it.
Theodore Vegh
Theodore Vegh 17 saatler önce
@Regina Billotti I just can't imagine a "Gentile European Race Female" in 1941 joining the Russian Army as a "front line soldier." It is virtually incomprehensible to my mind that a "Gentile European Race Female" would take a Rifle and kill someone's son. Women in 1941 were considered by most people to be wives and mothers- and certainly not Front Line Soldiers.
Regina Billotti
Regina Billotti 18 saatler önce
That makes no sense. The population of the USSR was 194 million in 1940. The Jewish population was about 2.6 million, or just over 1% of the total. There were about 800,000 female members of the army - including both front line combatants and auxiliary services. For all 800,000 women in the RA to be Jewish, that would be over half the total female Jewish population. There is no realistic reason to believe that recruitment/conscription was that selective.
Jomo Merritt
Jomo Merritt Gün önce
Great Knowledge! Very informational! Thank you for teaching and showing things that are generally not indicated or taught in schools.
Spencer Gorman
Spencer Gorman Gün önce
God what are the odds, the nazis were awful misogynistic bigots. Who would have guessed?
John Robinson
John Robinson Gün önce
The short version: Right-wingers are such happy go-lucky folk but they always lose in the end!
Gospod Nadskof
Gospod Nadskof Gün önce
Partizans WARE degenerates, who did unspeakable cruelites. In Yugoslavia partizans killed ower 150.000 civilians in Slovenia and Croatia and throw them into caves. Women, kids, babies, busines owners, factory ovners, priests, scolars... This was at the time 20% of population. And they did this after the war. 70 years later we are still finding mass graves all over the country.
Bert M
Bert M Gün önce
Damn Nazi's.
Briano Tuaño
Briano Tuaño Gün önce
In the war without treaty about captives, all captives including military boys will be killed except children, & single women specially virgins. If no one fought back, all will be slaves including men, except military women. Military women be killed because all captive women will assign as housemaids, and captive men as construction, and farmer slaves. .
Briano Tuaño
Briano Tuaño Gün önce
War captive women will be killed because they're dangerous to become housemaid slaves. They might harm their children, and old people even endangered them. Female combatant might be assigned to spy them.
Viaceslav Guzun
Viaceslav Guzun Gün önce
The horrors of World War II. This shall never happen again.
Sir Ridesalot
Sir Ridesalot Gün önce
Star Media (Russian) has a television series titled, "NIGHT SWALLOWS and dedicated to the women of the 36 Guards Female regiment of Night Bombers. Aka, The Night Witches. There are 8 episodes of 40+ minutes each. Available here on You Tube.
KURIA NJUGUNA
KURIA NJUGUNA Gün önce
HONESTLY, Only God and The Russians saved this planet from the Nazis.
jampumper
jampumper Gün önce
Great video. Clears the myth about the "decent" Wehrmacht.
Fortnite Pro’s
Fortnite Pro’s 20 saatler önce
Wars are messy - allsides in my opinion are guilty of atrocities. The soviets were the worst out of the lot. They were encouraged to rape the German woman by the soviet propaganda. The conduct of the soviets is never covered. It’s as if it’s okay because the victims are German. Same with Eisenhower’s death camps for German POWs, no one talks about it.
Aesop
Aesop Gün önce
Mark you can not label the Nazi - Soviet battles as being ideological in nature. One side tried to justify Lebensraum and the murder of millions by propaganda whilst the Soviet people had no need of encouragement to defend their Motherland. It is somewhat amusing, that the German sensitivities were hurt by the thought that the Soviets would allow women go to war. Just where were their sensitivities when it came to their mass murders of the innocents? Ask them and their reply would be " I saw nothing", "I heard nothing ", it was all Hitlers fault.
M Dawson
M Dawson Gün önce
I've never heard of this before. It's horrific. Does this explain the Russian abuse of German women?
Andrew Alley
Andrew Alley Gün önce
The only thing worse than being a Russian female prisoner of the Nazi's was to be a German Female Prisoner or Female in general of the Soviets.
Michael Gilbert
Michael Gilbert Gün önce
Adolf Eichmann spoke fluent Hebrew. Read many newspapers gleaning information re: deporting many sorts from crowded ghettos
txspyrate
txspyrate Gün önce
Sure would be nice if you would list your sources
Your No Beater
Your No Beater 2 gün önce
My wife family are Japanese, I went to her father's memorial mass. At the mass the shinto priest talk of his uncle a Japanese soldier fighting in China, he was captured by the Chinese and became a pow. His said the main issue was food one Japanese soldier was the toughest of them all and would take the food from the other soldiers. One day this soldier became sick and other soldiers turn on him and beat him up. He ended up in the corner of the pow camp slowly dying. The priest uncle came to the man and give him some of his food, the man said to him why are you helping me when have been so bad to you. His uncle said you are a human and so am I. The man died days later, his uncle a old soldier never told anyone of what it was like for Japanese soldiers in war, the priest was telling this at the time the Japanese government were pushing for Japanese army to go from defensive policy to allow its army to be military action outside Japan. In how the Japanese government trying to brainwashed the young people in to voting for this, the old people of Japan where against this because they knew what real was like. True story.
Soul of Arnor
Soul of Arnor 2 gün önce
Don't blame the soldiers, blame the commanders for instilling such desire for cruelty.
CC
CC 2 gün önce
People have not learn yet that fascism is an offshoot of capitalism. The child of the crisis of 1929. Tolerated for a decade because it put the restless workers in Europe in check and kept China under control. It became the enemy when it turned its sights towards countries in the reactionary capitalist "brotherhood": Great Britain, France and the US. Then the USSR become the ally that sacrificed itself to finish Nazism. Stalin was considered a hero by the people, they followed him because he had the wherewithal to lead the Communist Party in its task of holding together a young revolution. Capitalism is an evil ideology, currently turning on the hitherto privileged Western middle classes. But we don't believe any of this and that's why we have no solutions to the problems.
Bowtie1972
Bowtie1972 2 gün önce
1 minute on sponsoring of the 8 minutes in total...not cool.
Lucinda Gaskill
Lucinda Gaskill 2 gün önce
Too much ad talk.
danbiss87
danbiss87 2 gün önce
They probably executed the females immediatley for more reasons than they explain here...
ÆᛚᛚᑌᚱƐᗩ  ♪
Wait holup- Stalin was a bank robber?
Mamber
Mamber 2 gün önce
Yes, he and other revolutionaries did so to finance their political struggle, as they were already being persued as enemies of the Tsarist State.
AFSHAD JOUBEH
AFSHAD JOUBEH 2 gün önce
Thank you for the eye opener information.
Bruce Li
Bruce Li 2 gün önce
Sex slave, what else!!!!
Facts of the Confederacy
All wars have the average individual facing the most abuse. It’s sad
backup musicaccount
backup musicaccount 2 gün önce
Hmmm, can’t help but notice the Soviets who, according to the narrator, “viewed men and women as equal”, still separated men and women by sex per whatever military units they were in. Almost as if they recognized that mixed gender units can’t perform as adequately as combat requires…
tbob
tbob Gün önce
@backup musicaccount sure dig up the qoute that would be cool
backup musicaccount
@Winnie Nguyen I shouldn’t say the Russians as a whole, just the Bolsheviks specifically since they were the ones who were in power in Russia at the time. But communists suck is my point.
backup musicaccount
@tbob Patton had something to say about it and that he would’ve prevented it if he’d been allowed to take Berlin first but he was prevented by Eisenhower and the rest of the Allied top brass. I’ll dig up the exact quote if you guys want it but I’m just paraphrasing for now.
tbob
tbob Gün önce
@backup musicaccount Soviet war correspondent Natalya Gesse is qouted "They raped every German female from 8 to 80"
Winnie Nguyen
Winnie Nguyen Gün önce
@backup musicaccount that sounds about right
tcmtr6
tcmtr6 2 gün önce
Yeah Right.
mariohw 85
mariohw 85 2 gün önce
Fun fact according to my grand father an Indonesian pilot that the most law abiding and honorable soldier is Germany I forget most of it but he say that American and Japan like to drunk, play with woman but not German soldier
Shubo Das
Shubo Das 2 gün önce
This western countries gives human right and peace lectures to us Indians even USA got independent hundrade year before us but do not make a woman president.
Roland Vasquez
Roland Vasquez 2 gün önce
And at this very moment the german oppressors are reaping all the murderous hate they sowed within the bowels of 🔥👺🔥
Anna NOYB
Anna NOYB 2 gün önce
Those Nazis got very good at starving their prisoners.
 Wiz
Wiz 3 gün önce
Nazis and communists best friends
Hatii
Hatii 3 gün önce
We shouldn't forget the Russian cruel treatment of women from ,,liberated "countries.
Current Batches
Current Batches Saatler önce
@степан татьянин Bullshit.
степан татьянин
German professor debunked the myth of "atrocities" of the Red Army: Anglo-Saxons massively raped Germans Miriam Gebhardt “When the Soldiers Came” The historian Miriam Gebhardt proposed a new look at the problem of violence in post-war Germany. After the 45th year, on both sides of Berlin, as you know, thousands of Germans lost their honor. And contributed to this, the allied forces fighting against Nazism in World War II. However, traditionally the greatest blame for such abuse was placed on Soviet soldiers. And in the West, it is customary to call contacts between the winner and the defeated voluntary sexual act. The book by Gebhardt tells about what role the Yankees played in the history of Germany in the second half of the 40s. According to the researcher, the Americans blamed about 200 thousand Germans and are in no way inferior to their allies on the front of violence. One of the main sources for the work of the historian was the data of the Bavarian priests. Attempts to look at how the Americans fought against the Nazis have been made before. So, in 2003. American professor of forensics Robert Lilly discovered that by November 1945 in the United States, the tribunals had examined more than 11 thousand cases of sexual crimes.
степан татьянин
@Big Baby German professor debunked the myth of "atrocities" of the Red Army: Anglo-Saxons massively raped Germans Miriam Gebhardt “When the Soldiers Came” The historian Miriam Gebhardt proposed a new look at the problem of violence in post-war Germany. After the 45th year, on both sides of Berlin, as you know, thousands of Germans lost their honor. And contributed to this, the allied forces fighting against Nazism in World War II. However, traditionally the greatest blame for such abuse was placed on Soviet soldiers. And in the West, it is customary to call contacts between the winner and the defeated voluntary sexual act. The book by Gebhardt tells about what role the Yankees played in the history of Germany in the second half of the 40s. According to the researcher, the Americans blamed about 200 thousand Germans and are in no way inferior to their allies on the front of violence. One of the main sources for the work of the historian was the data of the Bavarian priests. Attempts to look at how the Americans fought against the Nazis have been made before. So, in 2003. American professor of forensics Robert Lilly discovered that by November 1945 in the United States, the tribunals had examined more than 11 thousand cases of sexual crimes.
Big Baby
Big Baby 2 gün önce
@Ant its pretty widely accepted that the soviet men were horrible to the civilians in countries they liberated on their way to Germany especially women. It wasnt punished it was accepted as Stalin said that his soldiers have "the right to enjoy the spoils of war", as he was referring to the women. Aleksander Solzhenitsyn wrote in his book The Gulag Archipelago that during WW2 it was acceptable for soviet soldiers to r@p3 and k!ll polish and german women but only grope and smack the soviet women on the behind.
Ant
Ant 2 gün önce
Who are we, you? who are you, anyway, an Internet hero? what do you know about the war, about the famine? western kids who don't know and haven't seen anything in their lives? who are you in this life? and how did the Soviet troops treat the Germans in general? do you know that looting and rape were punished, and the perpetrators were shot? these are individual cases multiplied by 1000 by your own historians. how do you like 13,000,000 children, old people, and just civilian Russians, Ukrainians and Belarusians killed, burned alive?! 13000000 ! pray that your Germany has not been completely wiped off the face of the earth. who are you to write such things here, you slobber?! your Europe surrendered almost all in 30 days except for the British, who were sitting on the defensive. where were your Americans when the USSR shed blood for you? 9 out of 10 German soldiers were on the eastern front , that is, they fought with the USSR , 9 out of 10! so who won the war? heroes ...., you never knew the war, mom's pu---s
Marvin Heemeyer
Marvin Heemeyer 3 gün önce
According to CNN & liberal Americans this was all Donald Trumps fault.
AWtify
AWtify 3 gün önce
the city of Krasnodon, USSR. After the liberation of the city by the Red Army, local residents ran to look for their children, former prisoners of the Germans. It soon became clear that all their children had been brutally murdered by the Germans on the eve of the retreat, dumped into a mine and pelted with grenades and stones. From the protocol of examination of corpses: -Ulyana Gromova, 19 years old, a five-pointed star is carved on her back, her right arm is broken, her ribs are broken -Lida Androsova, 18 years old, was extracted without an eye, an ear, an arm, with a rope around her neck, which strongly cut into the body. Baked blood is visible on the neck -Anya Sopova, 18 years old. She was beaten, hung by her plaits... Anya was lifted from the pit with one plait- the other broke off -Shura Bondareva, 20 years old, was extracted without a head and right breast, the whole body is beaten, bruised, has a black color -Tonya Ivanikhina, 19 years old, extracted without eyes, head tied with a handkerchief and wire, breasts cut out -Viktor Tretyaknevich, 18 years old. without a face, with a black-and-blue back, with shattered hands, no bullet marks were found on Victor's body, which means they dropped him alive into the mine...
Kevin B
Kevin B 3 gün önce
The Soviets did even worse to civilian German women.
степан татьянин
@Kevin B READ CAREFULLY and draw conclusions. Who fought for Hitler and the Wehrmacht? Every year on June 22, we remember the mournful date: On that tragic day, a war broke out between the great Eurasian power - the USSR and another coalition of European states, because, together with the Wehrmacht, the troops of Romania, Finland, Italy, Hungary, Slovakia, Croatia, Austria, only 15 European countries invaded the territory of the USSR !!! this historical memory and Russians will never forget In total, more than 3.5 million people from 15 European countries fought in the Wehrmacht troops (more than half a million - the Romanian army, almost 430 thousand - Hungarian troops, more than 270 thousand - Mussolini's troops!). Of these, 59 divisions, 23 brigades, several separate regiments, legions and battalions were formed during the war years. Many of them were named according to state and nationality !!! Blue Division - Spain "Wallonia" - the division included French, Spanish and Walloon volunteers, the Walloons were in the majority. The "Blue Division" was the only Wehrmacht unit to be awarded a "own" medal established in her honor !!! HUNGARIANS (MADYARS) 430 thousand - Hungarian troops In total, during the war years, 513,767 Hungarians were taken prisoner by the Soviet Union. "Galicia" - Ukrainians and Galicians "Bohemia and Moravia" - Czechs from Moravia and Bohemia "Viking" - from the Netherlands, Belgium and the Scandinavian countries Finland was an equally important ally of Nazi Germany. From the end of June 1941 to September 1944, there were sixteen infantry divisions on the Eastern Front, two jaegers and one cavalry brigade, a total of 340 thousand soldiers and officers, 2047 guns and mortars, 86 tanks and 307 aircraft. Denemark - Danes "Langemark" - Flemish Legion (Holland) "Nordland" - Scandinavian SS division "Nederland" - Dutch collaborators who fled to Germany after the occupation of Holland by the allies. "French Infantry Regiment 638", since 1943 was united with the newly organized "French SS Charlemagne Division" - the French. Army of Bulgaria This is not complete data, Europe is afraid to voice the archives because the numbers will increase 2 or 3 times!
Kevin B
Kevin B 2 gün önce
@степан татьянин From eyewitness accounts as the Soviet forces moved west they committed atrocities as unspeakable as them of the Western allies. Communism is really good at suppressing information and glorifying abominable acts as well as their Western counterparts...war is Hell.
степан татьянин
German professor debunked the myth of "atrocities" of the Red Army: Anglo-Saxons massively raped Germans Miriam Gebhardt “When the Soldiers Came” The historian Miriam Gebhardt proposed a new look at the problem of violence in post-war Germany. After the 45th year, on both sides of Berlin, as you know, thousands of Germans lost their honor. And contributed to this, the allied forces fighting against Nazism in World War II. However, traditionally the greatest blame for such abuse was placed on Soviet soldiers. And in the West, it is customary to call contacts between the winner and the defeated voluntary sexual act. The book by Gebhardt tells about what role the Yankees played in the history of Germany in the second half of the 40s. According to the researcher, the Americans blamed about 200 thousand Germans and are in no way inferior to their allies on the front of violence. One of the main sources for the work of the historian was the data of the Bavarian priests. Attempts to look at how the Americans fought against the Nazis have been made before. So, in 2003. American professor of forensics Robert Lilly discovered that by November 1945 in the United States, the tribunals had examined more than 11 thousand cases of sexual crimes.
степан татьянин
Lines from the diary of the American military signalman of the US Army Edward Wise: “We moved to Oberhunden. Colored guys staged the hell out of here. They set fire to houses, cut Germans in a row with razors and raped them. ” . By the end of September 1945, food standards for Germans located in the territory controlled by US troops had been reduced; moreover, its calorie content was less than the American breakfast. Immediately after that, the head of the American military police, Gerald F. Bean, said that the issue of rape is not an acute issue, this issue can be resolved with a bar of chocolate, a piece of soap or a loaf of bread, of course, after that the number of calls to the military police came to naught The London Weekly Review of October 25, 1945 described it this way: "Homeless young girls openly offer themselves for food or an overnight stay ... it's very simple, they only have one thing left for sale, and they sell it ... as a way to die, it can be even worse than hunger, but it puts off death for months, or even years. " Dr. George N. Shuster, President of Hunter College, wrote in December 1945 in the Catholic Digest after visiting the US occupation zone: "You said it all when you say that Europe is now the place where a woman lost the long-standing struggle for decency, because only the shameless ones survived." Sylvester Michelfelder, Lutheran pastor, wrote in Christian Century: "Crowds of unpunished bandits in English and American uniforms rob trains. Women and girls are raped in front of everyone. They are forced to walk naked."
Russell Nixon
Russell Nixon 3 gün önce
A grim l tale of a how Germany's army behaved in a horrific and shameful way.
Roman Dybala
Roman Dybala 3 gün önce
My uncle fought in WW2 as a 17 year old. He said the Russians were incredibly cruel to German women as the soldiers moved towards Berlin. Im sure he was unaware at the time the atrocities heaped on these Rusiian women soldiers by the Germans. War has no winners.
schrens
schrens Gün önce
@Egorian I also read a german article of a contemporary witness that I trust and it described a german peasant coming to a soviet officer complaining about his daughter(s) being raped by a soviet soldier. The witness described how the officer beat the soldier to death while the peasant was standing next to the scene. Then I read a lot about young German women fleeing (regularly) to the woods, because otherwise they would have been raped (again) by soviet soldiers. Also contemporary witnesses, and for me also trustworthy.
Egorian
Egorian Gün önce
@степан татьянин thank you for making it clear for everyone. My sources (passed away family members) told me that any soviet soldier caught doing that was often shot on the spot. Russian commanders knew soldiers wanted revenge and passed out info that rape or theft will be punished by death.
степан татьянин
Подонок ! German professor debunked the myth of "atrocities" of the Red Army: Anglo-Saxons massively raped Germans Miriam Gebhardt “When the Soldiers Came” The historian Miriam Gebhardt proposed a new look at the problem of violence in post-war Germany. After the 45th year, on both sides of Berlin, as you know, thousands of Germans lost their honor. And contributed to this, the allied forces fighting against Nazism in World War II. However, traditionally the greatest blame for such abuse was placed on Soviet soldiers. And in the West, it is customary to call contacts between the winner and the defeated voluntary sexual act. The book by Gebhardt tells about what role the Yankees played in the history of Germany in the second half of the 40s. According to the researcher, the Americans blamed about 200 thousand Germans and are in no way inferior to their allies on the front of violence. One of the main sources for the work of the historian was the data of the Bavarian priests. Attempts to look at how the Americans fought against the Nazis have been made before. So, in 2003. American professor of forensics Robert Lilly discovered that by November 1945 in the United States, the tribunals had examined more than 11 thousand cases of sexual crimes.
RICK LANDRIO
RICK LANDRIO 2 gün önce
Yes unfortunately it was in retaliation of whatthe germans did to russian well educated woman in combat ..sadly the civilian german woman who hadno clue of there countries atrocities had to pay forwhat there german army did to female russian soldiers
Tianen Chen
Tianen Chen 3 gün önce
The USSR viewed men and women as equal? The Nazis had a famous female movie director for the most important propaganda films. What high roles did Soviet women play?
Akshay Jadhav
Akshay Jadhav 3 gün önce
And aftermath of the story is in 1945 Rape of Berlin happened as revenge by stalins order
Dan Aelenei
Dan Aelenei 3 gün önce
The victors are never wrong ... Propaganda film, suitable for red commisars use. Stalin would be proud of you.
George Gordon
George Gordon 3 gün önce
Mark, any info on what Russian female soldiers thought of the mass rape of German women?
Didi H
Didi H 3 gün önce
Yes, I mean, that a woman ... that was so completely against our order and against our soldierly concept ... We have seen it once, so there is ... God ... on the roadside ... one Was a Russian in a uniform, her pants were taken off and her thighs apart, and so she was then laid down on the street. So that was an expression that was definitely used among the wild compatriots ... somehow, we were men among us, so here hate and incomprehension could somehow turn into anger. [349] Even women who had experienced sexual violence were confronted with the allegation that they had volunteered with the Germans. The former field nurse Tatiana Polikarpowna Nanijewa was captured by the Germans in 1942 as a member of the Red Army and imprisoned in a camp in southern Poland. During her imprisonment, she witnessed a series of brutal rapes by German guards. [148] From:Eroberungen 1941-1945
Garrick
Garrick 3 gün önce
Well, going into this I was hoping the answer was that the Germans gave them a cup of tea, and then set them to work darning socks for the rest of the war. I didn't have too much confidence though.
Nigel Kent
Nigel Kent 3 gün önce
I know a man who's mother was an SOE agent she and her mother were snitched on to the Gestapo they ended up in ravensbruck concentration camp they both survived they were getting British and Canadian air men out of Belgium I think but not sure one of the Canadian airmen was called Wally cant remember his second name she knew bomber Harris and the man I knew baught a picture of him sitting on bomber Harris,a knee they wrote a book about her a child at war she was a member of the special forces club in England shes passed away now but her son the one sitting on Harris,s knee lovely bloke
GoTaMa
GoTaMa 3 gün önce
Im so sick watching ww2 again and again it was disgusting
Bsizzle
Bsizzle 3 gün önce
I mean neither nation followed the Geneva Convention on the Eastern Front so it was just brutal warfare
Lawrence Rouse
Lawrence Rouse 3 gün önce
Good, video. I have read a lot of history and one thing I am so tired of hearing about are the atrocities of the Germans. While I would not seek to minimize what they did, the Soviets were far worse, then and even after the war, and well into the 1980's. Untold millions have died at the hands of the Soviets and the numbers and atrocities pale compared to Nazi Germany.
CC
CC 2 gün önce
Unlikely. Though the US post WW2 had huge interest in making look so. The Nazi crimes were bigger than the USSR's. The US crimes since '45 have overtaken everything Stalin may have done. It's just convenient lies to rubbish a revolution of the people that shook the capitalist world.
lear0612
lear0612 2 gün önce
I think its odd in western education we never speak about the atrocities Russians commited against their own people and other people pre WW2 and post WW2.
Mickey Mouse
Mickey Mouse 3 gün önce
No sources? Hollywood historian.
eric morgan
eric morgan 3 gün önce
The slogan “Never Again” requires the knowledge of What Happened in order to avoid a repeat. The fact that WW2 is Not Taught, indicates quite clearly, that those teaching our children are Utterly Unworthy of being called “Educators” And should, More Accurately be termed Socialist “Propagandists”.
ISPEAKU
ISPEAKU 3 gün önce
One of hundreds of reasons why stories of raped Berlin never move Russians.
Lost Pony
Lost Pony 4 gün önce
Badly, i presume.
Wannabe
Wannabe 4 gün önce
They were raped or shot. Nazis were horrible to the soviets. When the red army swept the eastern front and moved toward Germany they were equally horrible to the Germans. Women and even young girls were raped to death and eventually shot when they got tired of them. Sick evil people
First Last
First Last 3 gün önce
You realize the Russians did that to all the German women when they invaded right? You know the Bolsheviks during bloody Sunday raped women, killed all men that they found, and nailed babies to barns a couple days before Hitler invaded Poland? You people watch too many movies.
Jo Rad
Jo Rad 4 gün önce
This was not the thinking of all Germans but only upper commanders. This is absolutely horrendous only the upper commanders would think like this. Thank you for the very informative video!
Samrat Mukherjee
Samrat Mukherjee 4 gün önce
Atrocities of torture is ok, but you need to come up with the notion behind these torture, why was it so harsh?? War prisoners should be treated with respect, then why the immense harsh behaviour
Zack Wang
Zack Wang 4 gün önce
Soviet soldiers raped civilian women in berlin though
ChairmanMo
ChairmanMo 4 gün önce
And people still wonder why the Red Army went berserk once they got into Germany???
yow
yow 4 gün önce
So sad that russian female known for their beauty
Silver & Gold are Money
This was an astonishing video Mark. Thank you for the history lesson.
ziblot123
ziblot123 4 gün önce
Weibe means wives. Partisans are shot by all sides. This isnt a German role only.
CatMom
CatMom 4 gün önce
Disgusting, od course.
Ross W
Ross W 4 gün önce
The thought that humanity was this cruel to each other is amazingly sad. You would see your enemy as sub-human to be able to do these things. And it's still happening today in places like North Korea, China.. the Middle East. Sickening.
3John16
3John16 4 gün önce
MSM is pushing the same Us vs them tactics on unvaccinated Covid. These tactics did not start out this cruel- it was a systematic step by step process. We see this happening today.
69drin
69drin 4 gün önce
War is always ugly.
Alex Max
Alex Max 4 gün önce
I love this channel but sometimes u're such a brown noser Mark.... Yes, Soviet women were equally seen sometimes....equally worthless... You seem to gloss over the repeating beating and rapes they had to endure from their own "comrades"... There are enough stories right here on TRvid with whole women dormitories that had their doors smashed and were mass raped..... And you talk about the "poor soviet army" and rape? The nerve... The poor Soviet army was synonyms with rape towards the end of the war.... Leaving a trail of blood and victims (over 50% of them children) wherever they went... Talk to anyone who lives in a country Soviets saw as hostile....everyone has a rape story... I won't even mention the fall of Berlin... The nerve...
deez
deez Gün önce
@Alex Max lmao stop with the mental gymnastic bro. Wtf are you even quoting, time stamp it, did you even watch the video. Him establishing context on the germans view on the role of women helped him explain why they were shot on sight instead of taking them prisoner. Stop trying to deflect to "hur dur soviet rape too" what's the point of doing that? Are you trying to say the germans were more virtuous because they rape less?, like you said everyone has a rape story, and the story being talked about isnt about rape. No one is justifying anything it's just history, everything he said in the video was 100% fact. absolute crackup as well if you think the german army wasnt a rape army. Ahahaha "just trust me bro they told me they dont rape" says the guy who thinks a historian is distorting history as he distorts history himself ironic, get out of here it's been documented, do some research, they have been plenty of bastards born out of slavic woman from german rapist. They also set up brothels as well and used captured Jewish and slavic women as comfort women
Alex Max
Alex Max Gün önce
@deez Because the way he portraits the situation is "heroic soviet women" vs second class citizen German women and everyone knows that's bullshit.... If this was strictly about Russian women why bring out German women and how they're treated? Nobody was worst treated then Russian women by their own comrades... And no, the German army was not a "rape army" like soviets....You got executed for rape in the German army...Stop trying to justify The Russian rape army
deez
deez 3 gün önce
he said "equal enough to bare arms" but beside the point, the topic is about captured soviet female soilders and their treatment by the germans. not soviet female soldiers treatment in the red army. like you said everyone has a rape story, berlin, german invasion into eastern europe, but how are they relevant to the topic?
Christina Sornbutnark
Night Witches how cool
John Ashley
John Ashley 5 gün önce
So this is why women are queuing up to join western armies, in the hope that they'll be butchered by the enemy when they're captured. Makes a change from washing-up at least?!
Nuke China
Nuke China 5 gün önce
Spread those legs soldier because I’m coming in
James Powlett
James Powlett 5 gün önce
Yes but both were leftists both the communist s and the nazis , so there ideologies were not that different, your another so called historian that can’t even grasp the fact that the nazis and the soviets were one and the same in ideology , the nazis were not far right they were far left by the way
Reg regan
Reg regan 5 gün önce
Well the Russians definately got their payback on the Germans in the end, you reap what you sow!
Anthony Mooney
Anthony Mooney 5 gün önce
Would be an absolute blockbuster should make a film terribly courageous and heartbreaking as well
Martin Reintal
Martin Reintal 5 gün önce
After watching this I still cannot tell if the Nazis were more threatened or just disgusted by these fighting females. Perhaps both?
Aguijon
Aguijon 5 gün önce
You should do a video about Hitler's paintings and where are they now
Sonraki
unorganized minecraft thoughts
8:26
görünümler 805 292
How I stay "skinny"
0:45
görünümler 1 235 714
Did Hitler Kill a King?
15:17
görünümler 429 000
Tuğçe Kandemir - Sakın Ola
2:48
görünümler 720 114
Fulya İle Umudun Olsun 75. Bölüm
2:2:54
En Çok Sokak Lezzetini Yiyen Kazanır!
18:42
BLACKPINK Performs Stay | Dear Earth
4:16
MILLION JAMOASI 2021-KONSERT DASTURI
2:10:30
JULIUS DEIN - FISH PRANK!! 🤣- #Shorts
0:56